
Ruling — Florida
Heritage v. Rapkin: Trade-Secret Records Wait for a Judge
The 1st DCA set the order of operations for trade-secret records under §624.4213. The record a public adjuster can use today is the variation report the ethics rule already requires.
Photo: NOAA via Wikimedia Commons (public domain)
In short
Florida's First District Court of Appeal quashed a Leon County order that would have handed sealed DFS investigation records to requesting adjusters before deciding whether the insurers' claimed trade secrets were exempt. Under §624.4213(2), a submitter that sues within 30 days of DFS's notice blocks release until a circuit court rules. The court took no position on trade-secret status, and the opinion is not yet final.
The Department of Financial Services filed 878 pages under seal in a Leon County records fight.1 Heritage's brief says it claims public-records exemptions on only 14 of them.5 On November 4, 2026, Florida's First District Court of Appeal held that a judge must rule on those claims before the sealed records reach the adjusters who asked for them.1
The requests are “tied to a Florida Department of Financial Services investigation into insurers' claim-handling practices.”1 Adjusters Benjamin Mandell and Jordan Lee filed their own requests and intervened beside the homeowners, the Rapkins.15 Lee told 60 Minutes in 2024 that he estimated the Rapkin claim at $231,368.57 and that Heritage's version came in at $15,469.48.4 “I handled 46 of them. 44 of them were changed,” he said.4 Those are his allegations. Heritage told 60 Minutes it had no intention to deceive,4 and it has denied the adjusters' allegations except to say that adjusters' names were inadvertently left off some revised reports.5
Leon County Circuit Judge Jonathan Sjostrom's March 26 order said the court “will not conduct the hearing in camera” and sent the sealed records to the requestor-intervenors under a confidentiality order.15 Lee served discovery on March 27.1 On April 16 the trial court granted only a temporary stay.1
How § 624.4213 sets the order of operations
The statute is mechanical. A company that submits documents to DFS and wants trade-secret protection must file a notice, mark each page “trade secret,” keep those pages separate, and swear that the information has value, has been protected, can't reasonably be obtained by legitimate means and is “not publicly available elsewhere.”2 When a records request reaches marked pages, DFS “shall promptly notify” the submitter, who “has 30 days following receipt of such notice to file an action in circuit court.”2 If suit is filed, the department “may not release the documents pending the outcome of the legal action.”2 If not, the claim is waived and DFS “shall release the document as requested.”2 The First DCA read that sequence literally: “where a timely action is filed, section 624.4213(2), Florida Statutes, bars release of records containing claimed trade secrets until a circuit court rules on their trade-secret status.”1

The panel had no problem with a hearing. “Resolving the exemption at a hearing rather than through in camera review would have been permissible; ordering production and full participation of the requestor-intervenors before deciding exempt status is not.”1 Lee's next-day discovery made the point: “The risk here is not hypothetical.”1 The court also kept the burden on the insurers: “The burden of proving trade-secret status rests on the party asserting it.”1
The panel did not decide what the pages are. “We take no position on whether the records are trade secrets or otherwise exempt.”1 On remand, the trial court must decide through “a confidentiality-preserving in camera inspection or evidentiary hearing that does not disclose the records to those seeking them.”1 The opinion is not yet final, pending any timely motion under Rules 9.330 or 9.331.1 Chip Merlin, Mandell's counsel, expects the judge to review the records in camera, and his team is considering an appeal.5
The record a PA can demand today
Any carrier submission marked and defended within 30 days can sit behind a circuit court ruling, and this one has been in litigation since at least March 2026.21
The faster record is the one Florida's adjuster ethics rule already requires.
Since April 21, 2025, Rule 69B-220.201(3)(m) has bound company, independent and public adjusters on residential claims.3 “Any changes made to a prior detailed estimate of the amount of the loss provided to the insured or insurer must include an explanation which provides the reason for any change made.”3 The modifying adjuster must keep supporting documentation, put “his or her name on the modification document,” and deliver the line-item estimate with “a variation report, or other similar report showing whether and to what extent the program was modified by the adjuster.”3 Undocumented changes to program prices or “any other program input or output” are “strictly prohibited.”3
So on every revised carrier estimate on a residential claim, ask in writing for the variation report, the reason for each change and the name of the adjuster who made it, cite the rule, and log the date of the request and what came back. A missing name or report becomes a documented gap without a public-records request, the kind of ownership trail at issue in the Texas Beryl estimate audit-trail suit.
The rule binds the PA's own estimates too, so a PA's revised number needs its own explanation, name and variation report.3 Program inputs have drawn disputes before, as in Allstate's Arizona settlement over nonmaterial depreciation, and the Florida rule requires any modification of them to be documented.3
Sources cited
- Heritage Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Rapkin, No. 1D2026-1153 (Fla. 1st DCA Nov. 4, 2026)— Florida First District Court of Appeal
- Section 624.4213, Florida Statutes (2026), Trade secret documents— The Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine)
- Rule 69B-220.201, Florida Administrative Code, Ethical Requirements (effective April 21, 2025)— Florida Department of State, Florida Administrative Code
- Whistleblowers claim insurance companies shortchanged Florida homeowners after Hurricane Ian (60 Minutes transcript, Sept. 29, 2024)— CBS News
- Florida Appeals Court Bars Release of Trade Secret Info in Heritage Claims Litigation (Nov. 5, 2026)— Insurance Journal
Built for where claims are going.
Carrier automation is not slowing down. claimOS gives the recovery side the same leverage: AI drafting grounded in the file, weather evidence on demand, and a record that holds up under review.