Investigation — Florida
Florida's AG Wants to Know Which Carriers Talked About the Anti-Public-Adjuster Clause
The subpoena asks about other carriers, and Florida's restraint-of-trade statute reaches only agreements. Velocity says the endorsement sits on commercial surplus-lines policies.
Photo: Riis2602 / CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons
In short
Florida's Attorney General subpoenaed Velocity Risk Underwriters on Oct. 20, 2026 for trade-group, insurer-communication and agreement records, without naming a statute. claimOS found no Florida statute voiding anti-public-adjuster clauses, so the pending FAPIA/NAPIA lawsuit pairs FDUTPA and common-law claims with a § 542.18 count alleging an agreement among carriers. Velocity says the endorsement goes to commercial surplus-lines insureds.
On Oct. 20, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier sent a subpoena to Velocity Risk Underwriters, LLC demanding records of its trade-group memberships, its communications with other insurance companies, and any agreements to stop homeowners from using public adjusters.1 Uthmeier said his office is "looking into whether Velocity and other insurance companies worked together to ban public adjusters so they could pay out less money."1
The release names no statute. Claims Journal reported that the Attorney General "did not go into detail about what laws or regulations may have been broken by Velocity or others."9
We found no Florida statute that prohibits a policy provision barring the insured from hiring a public adjuster, after checking § 626.854, § 626.8796, the Surplus Lines Law at § 626.913 and following, and the 2025 and 2026 bills on the Florida Senate site containing "public adjuster." Section 626.854(15)(a) says "[t]he insurer may not exclude the public adjuster from its in-person meetings with the insured," then adds: "This section does not impair the terms and conditions of the insurance policy in effect at the time the claim is filed."7 Section 626.913(4) keeps chapter 627 off surplus-lines policies unless a provision is "specifically stated to apply to surplus lines insurers."4 SB 1268 would have added § 627.418(3), voiding any policy condition not authorized by the code unless the Office approved it; that provision did not mention public adjusters, and the bill died in Banking and Insurance on March 13, 2026.1114
Without a statute aimed at the clause, challengers have turned to general law, and Florida's antitrust statute reaches agreements between companies rather than the wording of one company's form.23
Why does the subpoena ask about other carriers?
Florida's restraint-of-trade statute is one sentence: "Every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade or commerce in this state is unlawful."3 Each of those words describes conduct by more than one party, and the Attorney General said he is looking into whether Velocity "and other insurance companies worked together."1
FAPIA and NAPIA pleaded it. Their complaint against Velocity was e-filed Oct. 9, 2025, in Miami-Dade's Complex Business Division, No. 2025-019878-CA-01.28 It pleads three counts: FDUTPA, a chapter 86 declaratory judgment that the clause is "void as against Florida public policy" and "an unenforceable post-loss condition," and a restraint-of-trade count pleaded as a per se violation of § 542.18.2 Paragraph 50 alleges that "Certain Underwriters at Lloyds, London and Interstate Fire & Casualty Company" are co-conspirators, and paragraph 40 alleges Velocity was "active and overt in the development, implementation and spread" of the endorsement "among surplus lines carriers in Florida."2

Section 542.27(3) lets the Attorney General investigate when he "suspects that a violation of this part ... is imminent, occurring, or has occurred," and § 542.28 authorizes a civil investigative demand for documents, sworn interrogatories and oral testimony, returnable no "earlier than 30 days from the date of service."10
| Who | Tool | Policies reached | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Massachusetts Legislature | Statute, G.L. c.175 § 2C | Admitted and surplus-lines P&C policies | Approved Aug. 7, 2026 |
| Florida Attorney General | Subpoena to Velocity; no statute named | Release frames it as homeowners' policies | Announced Oct. 20, 2026 |
| FAPIA + NAPIA | State suit: FDUTPA, declaratory judgment, § 542.18 | Velocity policies with the endorsement | Pending in Miami-Dade, filed Oct. 9, 2025 |
| Swerling Milton Winnick | Suit by a PA firm, removed to federal court | Velocity, No. 1:26-cv-12095 (D. Mass.) | Reply filed Oct. 26, 2026; no ruling shown |
Massachusetts went by statute, barring the clause for "non-admitted or surplus lines" insurers too (our chapter 187 post).12 Swerling's federal docket shows a reply filed Oct. 26, 2026, and no ruling.13
Where the endorsement sits
Velocity told Insurance Journal that its "non-admitted, surplus lines property policies containing this endorsement are issued to commercial insureds and it does not place personal residential homeowners' insurance policies in Florida."5 The Attorney General's release frames the issue around homeowners.1 The FAPIA complaint never uses "homeowner" or "residential"; it says "Florida consumers" and "policyholders."2
Commercial property was Florida's largest surplus-lines coverage in 2025 at $6.2 billion in premium on 299,531 policies, with premium down 5% and policy count up 42%; HO-3 homeowners policies numbered 130,058.6 The report does not say how many of those policies carry the endorsement. Louisiana bans the clause but exempts commercial surplus lines, as our surplus-lines carve-out post explains.

The complaint quotes two versions. Form A says the named insured "shall not hire, engage, retain, contract with, or otherwise utilize" a public adjuster, "whether or not licensed."2 Form B refers only to "a licensed public adjuster."2 Paragraph 38 alleges a Velocity letter warning that "[a]ny involvement of a Public Adjuster" in the claim "will constitute a breach of your insurance policy and could affect coverage for your loss."2
On a commercial E&S file, write down which wording the policy carries, Form A or Form B, with the form number and edition date from the endorsement schedule. Save any carrier letter invoking it, dated on receipt, beside the date of loss and the date you were retained. We found no Florida ruling that holds the clause unenforceable.
Velocity said it is cooperating.5 As of Claims Journal's Oct. 23, 2026 report, the Miami-Dade suit was pending, and FAPIA general counsel Jonathan Zachem said the Attorney General's probe won't affect it.9
Questions from commercial files
Does Florida's public adjuster statute stop a carrier from enforcing the clause?
No. Section 626.854(15)(a) bars an insurer from excluding a public adjuster from its in-person meetings with the insured, but the same section says it does not impair the policy terms in effect when the claim is filed. We found no Florida statute that voids the clause.
Does chapter 627 apply to a surplus-lines commercial property policy?
It depends. Section 626.913(4) says chapter 627 does not apply to surplus lines insurance except where a provision is specifically stated to apply to surplus lines insurers.
Has a Florida court ruled the anti-public-adjuster endorsement unenforceable?
No. The FAPIA and NAPIA suit against Velocity in Miami-Dade was pending as of October 2026 reporting, and we found no ruling.
Should I keep the carrier's letter invoking the endorsement?
Yes. The FAPIA complaint quotes a Velocity letter warning that public adjuster involvement would breach the policy. A dated copy shows which wording the carrier relied on and when it raised it.
Sources cited
- Attorney General James Uthmeier Launches Investigation into Homeowners Insurers for Blocking Outside Claims Assistance (Oct. 20, 2026)— Office of the Attorney General of Florida
- Complaint, FAPIA and NAPIA v. Velocity Risk Underwriters, LLC, No. 2025-019878-CA-01 (Fla. 11th Jud. Cir., e-filed Oct. 9, 2025)— Miami-Dade Circuit Court filing, hosted by Insurance Journal
- Section 542.18, Florida Statutes, Restraint of trade or commerce— The Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine)
- Section 626.913, Florida Statutes, Surplus Lines Law— The Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine)
- Florida AG Says His Office Investigating 'Anti-Public Adjuster' Endorsements in Policies (Oct. 21, 2026)— Insurance Journal
- 2025 Annual Report (data as of Feb. 23, 2026)— Florida Surplus Lines Service Office
- Section 626.854, Florida Statutes, "Public adjuster" defined; prohibitions— The Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine)
- FAPIA and NAPIA File Joint Complaint Against Anti-Public Adjuster Endorsements (Oct. 13, 2025)— National Association of Public Insurance Adjusters
- Florida AG Says His Office Investigating 'Anti-Public Adjuster' Endorsements in Policies (Oct. 23, 2026)— Claims Journal
- Chapter 542, Florida Statutes, Part I, Florida Antitrust Act of 1980 (§§ 542.27, 542.28)— The Florida Legislature (Online Sunshine)
- SB 1268 (2026), bill text as filed— The Florida Senate
- Acts of 2026, Chapter 187, An Act Further Regulating Insurance Claims— Massachusetts General Court
- Swerling Milton Winnick Public Insurance Adjusters, Inc. v. Velocity Risk Underwriters, LLC, No. 1:26-cv-12095 (D. Mass.) docket— CourtListener
- SB 1268 (2026), bill history— The Florida Senate
Built for where claims are going.
Carrier automation is not slowing down. claimOS gives the recovery side the same leverage: AI drafting grounded in the file, weather evidence on demand, and a record that holds up under review.