Appraisal — Kentucky
A Kentucky Court Threw Out a $498,676 Appraisal Award. The Scope Came From the PA's File.
State Farm agreed to appraise a copper theft in one building, and the umpire priced six. The court found the agreed scope in the public adjuster's own paperwork and vacated all $498,676.16.
Photo: Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress / Public domain via Wikimedia Commons
In short
In 453 Laurel Rd Holdings, LLC v. State Farm (E.D. Ky. Oct. 28, 2026), the court vacated a $498,676.16 umpire award in full because State Farm had agreed to appraise only a copper wire and plumbing theft, while the award valued six buildings. With the policy silent on appraisal scope, the court defined the panel's task from the public adjuster's engagement letter, police report, photos, inspections and a $116,953.17 sworn proof of loss, and sent the parties to discovery.
State Farm's email of Dec. 22, 2025 agreed to appraise one thing at a six-building apartment complex in London, Kentucky: "the theft claim for copper wire and copper plumbing."1 Property damage it said had not been previously disclosed would wait on more investigation.1 The umpire's award came back on May 14, 2026 at $498,676.16, covering all six buildings, HVAC and cabinetry included.1 On Oct. 28, 2026, Judge Robert E. Wier vacated all of it.1
The policy's appraisal clause covers mechanics, from picking appraisers to the rule that any two bind.1 On what goes in front of the panel it is silent. "Nothing in the Policy clarifies how, or if, the parties may limit the scope of an appraisal," the court wrote.1 Kentucky lets a court set an award aside for "a lack of understanding or completion of the contractually assigned task," under the Court of Appeals' 2021 Parrish decision.3 So the court built the assigned task from the file the insured's public adjuster had assembled.

The engagement letter retained the adjuster for a claim "arising from a loss due to theft which occurred on or about 4/25/24" at the Laurel Road property.1 The London Police Department report of May 1, 2024 described stolen "electrical wiring and copper piping."1 On June 26, 2024 the adjuster sent State Farm nine photographs depicting, in the court's words, "the extent of the loss as limited to a single building."1 She hosted two State Farm inspections, and the field adjuster's unrebutted affidavit says she confirmed each time that only Building 5 and only copper theft were at issue.1 Her June 2024 estimate ran to $448,936.50 with cabinetry, drywall and windows, but in September 2024 she signed a sworn proof of loss on State Farm's form at $116,953.17, noting that the insured was still "waiting on engineer report."1 State Farm's Nov. 7, 2024 estimate of $114,634.91 sat "just $2,318.26" below the sworn figure.1
On that record, only the copper theft had "ripened into a dispute over valuation."1
The umpire adopted the insured's appraiser's categories, and the award itemized no copper wiring or plumbing materials, according to State Farm's appraiser.1 In the court's words, it "hardly touches on the actual field of the disputed appraisal."1
Why didn't the written objection hold?
The insured invoked appraisal and named its appraiser on Dec. 5, 2025; State Farm named its own on Dec. 24.1 Plaintiff's counsel wrote on Jan. 2, 2026, "for the record," that "we dispute that this claim 'was not previously disclosed'" and that "my client made a claim under its all-risk policy."1 It came after both appraisers were seated, it disputed the "not previously disclosed" label rather than expressly rejecting the copper-only scope, and the appraisal went forward anyway.1 The court said the insured pointed only to the adjuster's "outlier estimate" and "a single email exchange."1 The insured filed no sworn statements from its appraiser or the umpire, which the court said would only have proved the appraisers "were valuing wholly different scopes."1
The court vacated the entire award, salvaged no copper-only portion and sent the parties to discovery, writing that affirming would be "a windfall for Plaintiff and would do violence to the intended mutual economies in the appraisal mechanism."1 Our post on One Church v. Brotherhood Mutual showed how hard a signed award is to break; here a carrier unwound one on scope, with the bad-faith counts bifurcated since September 2025.1

Scope work on your own files
The engagement letter's loss description should cover the whole claim and get amended in writing when the claim grows. Kentucky's PA-contract statute now requires "A description of the loss or damage and its location, if applicable," part of the statute we covered in our Kentucky HB 568 post.2 A sworn proof of loss narrower than your estimate should be marked partial, with the reserved buildings and items listed; a bare "waiting on engineer report" note did not carry the larger claim.1 Show and photograph everything you claim at the inspection. Answer a conditional appraisal acceptance on scope, in writing, before the carrier's appraiser is named and the panel starts pricing. Then ask for an itemized award that ties each line to the agreed scope, because the court began its analysis with "the face of the award."1
This is one federal trial court applying Kentucky law, binding no state court, and a first: "Since Parrish, no court in the Commonwealth has interpreted this term as it applies to rescinding an appraisal award."1 The facts were lopsided, the presumption still favors awards, and the insured's broader claim "remains to be determined."1 The opinion gives the award as $498,676.16 on page 4 and $498,676.18 on page 15, and we use the first.1
Scope questions, answered
Can a Kentucky court vacate an appraisal award because the panel valued more than the agreed scope?
Yes. In 453 Laurel Rd Holdings, LLC v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 6:25-cv-00094 (E.D. Ky. Oct. 28, 2026), the court vacated a $498,676.16 umpire award covering six buildings because the agreed task was a copper wire and plumbing theft, applying the Parrish test for a lack of understanding of the contractually assigned task.
Did the court keep the copper-theft portion of the award?
No. The 453 Laurel Rd Holdings court set aside and vacated the entire May 14, 2026 award, did not order a new appraisal, and sent the parties to discovery. The insured's broader claim remains to be determined in the litigation.
Can a public adjuster's own documents define the scope of appraisal?
Yes. With the State Farm policy silent on limiting appraisal scope, the 453 Laurel Rd Holdings court relied on the public adjuster's engagement letter describing a loss due to theft, the police report, nine photos of one building, two inspection walk-throughs, and a $116,953.17 sworn proof of loss on State Farm's form.
Does this ruling bind Kentucky state courts?
No. 453 Laurel Rd Holdings is a federal district court decision applying Kentucky law, and the court noted that since Parrish v. Schroering (Ky. Ct. App. 2021) no Kentucky court had interpreted the lack-of-understanding test as it applies to rescinding an appraisal award. State courts may read the standard differently.
Sources cited
- 453 Laurel Rd Holdings, LLC v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. 6:25-cv-00094-REW-HAI (E.D. Ky. Oct. 28, 2026), Memorandum Opinion & Order— U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo)
- KRS 304.9-433, Contract between public adjuster and insured— Kentucky General Assembly, Legislative Research Commission
- Kenneth D. Parrish, DMD, Ph.D., P.S.C. v. Schroering, No. 2019-CA-0634-MR (Ky. Ct. App. Apr. 16, 2021)— Cetient
Built for where claims are going.
Carrier automation is not slowing down. claimOS gives the recovery side the same leverage: AI drafting grounded in the file, weather evidence on demand, and a record that holds up under review.