The Thomas F. Eagleton U.S. Courthouse in St. Louis, Missouri, seat of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit

Trend: licensing and the First Amendment

Shamrock Hills: Iowa Can License the Inspection, Not the Roofer's Pitch

The Eighth Circuit kept Iowa's ban on contractors working claims. It also told the state that a roofer's insurance pitch is speech, and sent that half back for strict scrutiny.

By Andy Rouhafzai, Founder8 min read

Photo: U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri / public domain via Wikimedia Commons

In short

In Shamrock Hills v. Iowa (8th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026), the court upheld Iowa Code 522C.2(18) and 103A.71(3) against facial First Amendment and vagueness challenges, because attending inspections, writing estimates and submitting claims are conduct a state may license. It reversed 2-1 on the as-applied claim, holding that Iowa regulated speech as speech when it ordered a roofer to stop advertising that it helps with insurance claims, and remanded for strict-scrutiny review.

The warning notice went out on July 2, 2024.2 Its author was David Sullivan, assistant bureau chief of the Iowa Insurance Division's Market Regulation Bureau, and the recipient was an Iowa roofer, Shamrock Hills, LLC, which does business as Shamrock Roofing and Construction. A follow-up listed nearly two dozen examples of what the Bureau called unlicensed public adjusting. Several were sentences from the company's own pitch: that it would "assist with insurance claims," help homeowners "navigate the insurance red tape," and walk them "through everything with insurance reimbursement."1 On August 12, 2026, the Eighth Circuit ruled that Iowa may license the work those sentences describe, and that punishing the sentences themselves is a First Amendment problem the trial court never examined.1

What Iowa's contractor rule carries
Class D or C felony
Adjusting without a license
Class C when the loss tops $10,000, Iowa Code 522C.14
$40,000
Maximum fine per violation
Contractor dual-role ban, 103A.71(5)(b) and 714.16(7)
15% / 10%
Iowa public adjuster fee caps
Noncatastrophe / catastrophe claims, chapter 522C
2-1
Vote to revive the as-applied claim
Judge Kelly would not have reached it

Iowa comes at the contractor from both directions. Section 522C.2(18) defines a public adjuster as anyone who, for compensation, acts for or aids an insured in negotiating or effecting the settlement of a first-party property claim, or solicits that business, or advises an insured about such a claim.4 Adjusting without a license is a felony.1 Section 103A.71(3) then bars a residential contractor from representing, negotiating for, or offering or advertising to represent or negotiate for a homeowner on any insurance claim tied to roof or exterior repair work.5 The Division's own guidance puts it in one line: a contractor who gets a public adjuster license still cannot be the contractor and the public adjuster on the same project.1

Shamrock sued on September 25, 2024, arguing both statutes define public adjusting by what a person says and are void for vagueness.3 Judge Rebecca Goodgame Ebinger of the Southern District of Iowa dismissed the case on September 18, 2025, calling the scheme "a valid regulation of professional conduct."2

What did the Eighth Circuit actually decide?

Early headlines split. Some read the opinion as a win for Iowa, others as a revival of the roofer's case. Both readings are accurate about different halves of the disposition, written by Judge Grasz for a panel with Judges Kelly and Kobes.1

The court affirmed dismissal of the facial First Amendment challenge, holding that both statutes have a "plainly legitimate sweep." It affirmed dismissal of the vagueness challenges, facial and as-applied, because the Iowa Supreme Court has already said in detail what the statutes cover. And it reversed on the as-applied First Amendment claim, sending it back to the district court because Judge Ebinger never analyzed how Iowa actually applied the statutes to Shamrock through the warning notices.1

Judge Kelly joined everything except the remand. In her view Shamrock never developed an as-applied argument on appeal and never asked for the relief the majority gave, so the court should not have reached it.1

So the licensing law stands. What changed is the enforcement file a regulator can build against a contractor's marketing.

Inspections and estimates are conduct

The facial holding leans on an Iowa Supreme Court decision every public adjuster working the state should have on hand. In 33 Carpenters Construction, Inc. v. State Farm (Iowa 2020), the court held that a contractor aided an insured in effecting the settlement of a claim when it attended the carrier's inspection and submitted the first estimate.1 The Eighth Circuit treated those as acts, not messages. Neither one is "intended to be communicative," the panel wrote, borrowing a test the Supreme Court uses for expressive conduct.1

The panel then read section 522C.2(18)(a) to reach a longer list: assessing damage, preparing estimates, reviewing policies, evaluating coverage, submitting claims, devising strategy for pursuing coverage, and reviewing and filing legal documents.1 Some of that, it said, "no doubt" amounts to conduct, which is all a statute needs to survive a facial attack. And because the Iowa Supreme Court has read 103A.71(3) to regulate the same conduct as 522C.2(18), the contractor ban survived on the same reasoning.1

Conduct the Eighth Circuit said Iowa may license, versus contractor phrases it said Iowa regulated as speechConduct: licensableSpeech: strict scrutinyAttending the carrier'sinspectionSubmitting the firstestimate to the insurerAssessing damage,preparing estimatesReviewing the policy,evaluating coverageSubmitting claims, filinglegal documents"assist [them] with theclaims process""navigate the insurancered tape""assist withinsurance claims""walk[] [them] through everythingwith insurance reimbursement"Remanded: Iowa must justifythese applications, if it canFacial challenge to 522C.2(18) and 103A.71(3): rejected.Vagueness challenges: rejected. As-applied speech claim: revived 2-1.
Where Shamrock Hills puts the line. Left column: activities the Eighth Circuit treated as licensable conduct. Right column: phrases from Iowa's warning notices that the court said were regulated as speech. Source: Shamrock Hills v. Iowa, No. 25-2991 (8th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026).

The vagueness ruling runs on the same Iowa precedent. 33 Carpenters also held that directing an insured to file a claim and discussing the repair work with the insurer fall inside the statutes, and that telling an insured to file counts as "advising an insured." Nobody disputed that Shamrock had done things on that list, from submitting claims to negotiating with insurers and interpreting policies.1 A party whose conduct is clearly covered cannot complain that the edges are fuzzy.

Why did the court revive the roofer's speech claim?

Ten years ago, the opinion says, the analysis would have been short. The Eighth Circuit used to apply the professional speech doctrine and wave licensing laws through. The Supreme Court rejected that doctrine in NIFLA v. Becerra (2018), and this year's Chiles v. Salazar held that First Amendment protections "extend to licensed professionals much as they do to everyone else."1

Iowa's answer was that it regulates when Shamrock may practice public adjusting, which is conduct. The panel accepted that for inspections and estimates. It did not accept it for the advertising lines. When Iowa used the statutes to stop Shamrock from telling homeowners it would help with their claims, the court said, Iowa "regulated speech as speech," and that triggers strict scrutiny.1 Quoting Chiles, it added that the First Amendment "is no word game," and that its protections cannot be renamed away by labels.1

Split and felled trees beside a house in Cedar Rapids, Iowa, after the August 2020 Midwest derecho
Cedar Rapids, Iowa, days after the August 2020 derecho. Storm-cycle neighborhoods like this one are where a roofer's insurance pitch and an adjuster's license meet. Photo: Lyle Muller / IowaWatch via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

None of this tells the district court how to rule. Footnote 4 concedes that Iowa has a compelling interest in regulating public adjusters, then says fears of "regulatory impotence" are overblown given "the narrow nature of the relief at stake" and Iowa's other enforcement tools.1 It also notes that it "remains to be seen" whether Shamrock can prove anything. Strict scrutiny is hard for a state to pass, and a regulator that wants to keep policing contractor ads will have to show the restriction is narrowly tailored to the conflict-of-interest harm, a showing Iowa has not had to make yet.

Texas reached the same statute by a different road

The Texas Supreme Court decided almost the same fight in June 2024. In Texas Department of Insurance v. Stonewater Roofing, a roofer attacked the public adjuster license requirement in Insurance Code 4102.051(a) and the dual-capacity ban in 4102.163(a). The court rejected both First Amendment and vagueness claims, describing the statutes as "conventional licensing regulations that are triggered by the role a person plays in a nonexpressive commercial transaction, not what any person may or may not say."6

The Eighth Circuit cited Stonewater for the conduct point and then parted ways on the reasoning. Texas had leaned partly on agency: acting "on behalf of" someone creates a legal status, and "status and capacity are not speech." The panel called itself "skeptical" of that approach, warning it would let states curtail speech under the guise of regulating agency, and that it "sounds an awful lot like a watered-down version of the professional speech doctrine."1

Texas and the Eighth Circuit, side by side
Stonewater (Tex. 2024)Shamrock Hills (8th Cir. 2026)
PA licensing statute survives facial attack✓✓
Contractor dual-role ban survives✓✓
Vagueness challenge rejected✓✓
Agency/status theory accepted as a rationale✓✕
Roofer's as-applied speech claim alive✕✓
Sources: Tex. Dep't of Ins. v. Stonewater Roofing, No. 22-0427 (Tex. June 7, 2024); Shamrock Hills v. Iowa, No. 25-2991 (8th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026).

For a public adjuster the practical difference is narrow. Both courts let the state keep a contractor away from the inspection and the negotiation. Only one of them leaves room for the contractor to keep saying it helps with insurance.

Whose side were public adjusters on?

The state's. The National Association of Public Insurance Adjusters filed an amicus brief "in support of appellees and supporting affirmance."7 Its argument was about conflict of interest: a contractor doing the repair has every reason to adjust the claim toward its own invoice, and an unlicensed contractor acting as the insured's advocate "would allow contractors to take advantage" of homeowners at their most vulnerable.7 NAPIA also pointed to Iowa's own conduct rules. Section 522C.11 requires a public adjuster to serve "with objectivity and complete loyalty to the interest of the insured" and bars any financial interest in a claim beyond the contract fee.4 A roofer negotiating its own scope cannot meet either standard.

Iowa has been enforcing this for a while. In October 2024 the Division announced a consent order with Recon Roofing & Construction of Des Moines. According to Corridor Business Journal's account of the order, the company had advertised public adjuster services on its website and, on a Coralville loss from a March 2023 tornado, allegedly negotiated with the homeowner's insurer for higher costs and overhead.8 A court document cited in that account said none of the employees listed on the site had ever been licensed in Iowa as a public adjuster.

Exterior of the Iowa Judicial Branch Building in Des Moines, Iowa, which houses the Iowa Supreme Court
The Iowa Judicial Branch Building in Des Moines, home of the Iowa Supreme Court, which decided 33 Carpenters Construction v. State Farm in 2020. Photo: Paul R. Burley via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The adjuster reading of Shamrock Hills comes down to evidence. If you are building a complaint to the Division about a contractor working claims, the file that holds up after this opinion is the conduct file: who attended the carrier's inspection, whose estimate went to the desk adjuster, whose email argued line items or overhead and profit, who signed what on the insured's behalf. Screenshots of a contractor's "we handle insurance" banner are now the weakest exhibit in that packet, and possibly a protected one. The same split applies to your own practice in states with their own unauthorized-practice statutes, which we walked through for Virginia's 38.2-1845.24. And contractors are not the only ones trying to shrink the PA's role; carriers are doing it by endorsement, as in the surplus-lines anti-public-adjuster clauses.

What the opinion does not support is a claim that contractors in the Eighth Circuit (Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota and South Dakota) may now advertise freely. The panel decided a pleading question about one company's notices. As of November 12, 2026, we found no reported ruling on remand, and the opinion binds nobody in Texas, where Stonewater still governs. The statutes and filings cited here are public; how they apply to a particular contractor relationship is a question for Iowa counsel.

Sources cited

  1. Shamrock Hills, LLC v. State of Iowa, No. 25-2991 (8th Cir. Aug. 12, 2026) (slip opinion)— U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit
  2. Shamrock Hills, LLC v. Iowa, No. 4:24-cv-00340, Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Dismiss (S.D. Iowa Sept. 18, 2025)— U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa (via Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog)
  3. Shamrock Hills, LLC v. Iowa, Complaint, ECF No. 1 (S.D. Iowa filed Sept. 25, 2024)— U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa (via Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog)
  4. Iowa Code chapter 522C, Public Adjusters and Independent Adjusters (2026)— Iowa Legislature
  5. Iowa Code section 103A.71, Residential contractors (2026)— Iowa Legislature
  6. Texas Department of Insurance v. Stonewater Roofing, Ltd. Co., No. 22-0427 (Tex. June 7, 2024)— Supreme Court of Texas
  7. Brief of Amicus Curiae National Association of Public Insurance Adjusters in Support of Appellees, No. 25-2991 (8th Cir.)— National Association of Public Insurance Adjusters (via Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog)
  8. Roofing company reaches consent order with Iowa Insurance Division over alleged unlicensed public adjusting practices— Corridor Business Journal

Built for where claims are going.

Carrier automation is not slowing down. claimOS gives the recovery side the same leverage: AI drafting grounded in the file, weather evidence on demand, and a record that holds up under review.