State legal — Texas
A Supplement Is Not a Tolling Event: the Fifth Circuit on When a Texas Claim Clock Starts
A reopened claim, a $58,150.83 public adjuster estimate and two reinspections did not move a deadline set by one 2021 closing letter.
In short
In Schnatzmeyer v. State Farm Lloyds (5th Cir. Oct. 22, 2026), the Fifth Circuit held that a Texas property claim's limitations clock started when State Farm issued its estimate, paid $4,261.52 and closed the claim on March 12, 2021. Later reinspections and a public adjuster's $58,150.83 estimate did not restart it, because reconsideration only resets the clock if the insurer withdraws or changes its earlier decision. The ruling is unpublished and non-precedential.
Run the Texas clocks on your file.
Enter the dates you know. Clocks without a date show what starts them.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 542.055
Acknowledge, begin investigating, request itemsCarrier clock
15 calendar days from the date the carrier receives notice of the claim.
The trap is the request list: anything the carrier does not ask for here is contestable later as having been waived as a condition of payment.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 542.056
Accept or reject the claim in writingCarrier clock
15 business days from the date the carrier has every item it reasonably required (not the date of notice).
A 45-day extension exists only if the carrier explains why in writing before this deadline expires; arson claims run a flat 30 days. A lapse with no written decision is a § 542.060 interest event in itself; the 60-day § 542.058 pay clock has been running since the carrier had every requested item.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 542.057
Pay the amount the carrier agreed to payCarrier clock
5 business days from the § 542.056 notice that the carrier will pay the claim or part of it.
Computed from the acceptance notice. If the carrier conditioned payment on an act by the insured (a signed release, an endorsement), count 5 business days from the date of that act instead (§ 542.057(b)). A missed § 542.057 date is a § 542.060 interest event on its own, before the 60-day outer limit runs.
- —Tex. Ins. Code §§ 542.058, 542.060
Prompt-pay outer limit: payment due in fullCarrier clock
60 days from the date the carrier has every item, statement, and form it reasonably requested under § 542.055. The clock does not wait for acceptance.
Past the deadline: statutory interest on the unpaid amount plus attorney fees under § 542.060. The rate is 18% a year, except on a Chapter 542A claim (hail, wind, flood, and other forces of nature), where it is the Finance Code § 304.003 judgment rate plus five points, set on the date of judgment. Strict liability; good faith is not a defense, and partial payments do not toll the clock on the unpaid balance.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 542A.003
Pre-suit notice (force-of-nature claims)Hard deadline
Written notice to the insurer no later than the 61st day before filing suit.
Must state the acts or omissions, a specific amount owed, and attorney fees as hours worked times hourly rate with contemporaneous records. Serving only a third-party adjuster does not satisfy the statute; deficient notice is grounds for abatement under § 542A.005.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 2301.010(b)
Suit-limitations floor: two years from the carrier decisionHard deadline
Two years from the date the carrier accepts or rejects the claim.
The contractual limitations period cannot end before the EARLIER of this date or three years from the date of loss. Appraisal demands, mediation, and carrier delay do not toll it absent a written tolling agreement.
- —Tex. Ins. Code § 2301.010(b)
Suit-limitations outer floor: three years from the date of lossHard deadline
Three years from the date of loss.
Applies with the two-year-from-decision floor: the period cannot end before the earlier of the two. Any tighter policy clause is void on its face.
- —SB 458 (89R) / Tex. Ins. Code ch. 1813
SB 458 mandatory binding appraisalContext
Policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026, when the dispute is solely about the amount of loss.
The appraisal award is binding except for fraud, accident, or material mistake. Paying through appraisal does not insulate the carrier from § 542 prompt-payment damages; the § 542.060 interest meter keeps running past the § 542.058 deadline.
Computed from the claimOS field guide for this state. Clocks the guide states as plain days are counted as calendar days; business days are counted as weekdays. Informational, not legal advice. Verify against the current statute and policy language.
State Farm closed a Dallas freeze-loss claim by phone on March 12, 2021, the same day it issued a decision letter and a $4,261.52 payment.1 The Fifth Circuit started the limitations clock on that date and never moved it. The insureds sued 966 days later, after a second freeze, a public adjuster, a $58,150.83 estimate and two more rounds of State Farm review.1
Which day the clock started
The policy gave the insureds two years and one day to sue on the contract, and Texas gives two years on statutory and common-law claims under Insurance Code section 541.162.12 The rule the panel applied is that those periods begin when coverage is denied, and a denial needs no particular words so long as the insurer's position is clear. Re-investigation does not undo one. In the panel's words, "reconsideration does not restart the limitations clock unless the insurer withdraws or changes its earlier decision."1
State Farm's later conduct was a reinspection on January 19, 2023, a May 15, 2023 letter reviewing the adjuster's estimate, and another reinspection on September 23, 2023 after a presuit demand. None of it changed the March 2021 position, so the deadlines were March 12, 2023 for the common-law and statutory claims and March 13, 2023 for contract and prompt-payment claims.1 Bad faith accrued on the same date.
Where the public adjuster came in
The insureds called State Farm about the ceramic tile on December 30, 2022, 658 days into the clock, after Schnatzmeyer reported that a water mitigation company had found tile damage the March 2021 inspection missed.1 They had never done the repairs State Farm paid for in 2021. In early February 2023 Schnatzmeyer told State Farm he had hired a public adjuster and would stop speaking with it, and Toni Henry's $58,150.83 estimate reached State Farm on February 16, 2023, 24 days before the first deadline.1
State Farm's May 2023 reply stood on the 2021 decision and added that the insureds had not completed repairs within two years of the loss, as the Duties After Loss provision required.1 The estimate arrived with 24 days left, and suit followed 235 days after the contract deadline. A claim estimate delivered to the carrier tolls nothing, and a carrier that answers it with a reasoned letter has still only re-investigated.
Two practical readings follow for a public adjuster taking over a file that is already a year or two old. Pull the earliest letter that combines a scope, a payment and a statement that the claim is closed, and date the limitations calendar from it, whatever later correspondence says. Then ask whether the carrier ever expressly withdrew or changed that decision, because a supplement request that the carrier simply declines does not count. Texas files that arrive after a second loss on the same property carry this risk in particular, since the second claim's activity can look like a live dialogue on the first. For the late-notice version of the same date-of-loss problem, see the Fifth Circuit's Gann decision, and for the broader deadline calendar see claimOS for public adjusters.
The opinion is unpublished and non-precedential under Fifth Circuit Rule 47.5, issued by a three-judge summary-calendar panel, and it applies settled law from Smith v. Travelers and Knott without making new rules.1 The insureds' argument that State Farm told them they could supplement within two years was forfeited because they never raised it in the district court, so the court did not decide it. This post relies on the slip opinion's account of the record; the policy form and the district court's summary-judgment opinion were not reviewed.
Sources cited
- Schnatzmeyer v. State Farm Lloyds, No. 25-11369 (5th Cir. Oct. 22, 2026) (per curiam, unpublished)— U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
- Texas Insurance Code ch. 541, Sec. 541.162— Texas Legislature Online
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code ch. 16, Sec. 16.070— Texas Legislature Online
Statutory clocks, tracked on every file.
claimOS calendars these deadlines automatically on each claim: acknowledgement, decision, payment, and the suit limitation, each with its code section attached and visible to the whole team.